re: JK Rowling is not a good writer or story teller

I don’t think you’re wrong about being a good writer. She’s not a good writer.

However, she’s a very capable story teller, at least with HP. HP wouldn’t be where it is if she wasn’t at least a decent story teller. You can be an average writer and still be a pretty good story teller. However, it could be that with what she had with HP practically wrote itself since her other stuff just isn’t good. It could also be that she’s just writing and the ideas are shite. Of course it doesn’t help that her writing is really subpar