re: The best hire ever?

Yea, I agree with most of what you said. I do agree that Waters is mostly responsible for the creative side and Gilmour/Wright for the musical side. I also blame Roger mostly for the separation and cheating us all out of years and years of great music. Im very happy that Gilmour and the rest stayed the course and did the music after Roger left. The Division Bell was one of the best albums in my opinion. The final cut on the other hand, that Roger was solely responsible for, was just terrible and the worst by far of the music labeled by Floyd