re: What will this years excuse be to put in an undeserving team into CFP?

quote:

---

The hypothetical proves that people's "divisions matter" mantra is stupid.

---

it proves nothing of the sort How could something that didn’t happen “prove” anything? Do they not teach basic logic on the capstone?

quote:

---

You think USC had a better claim to be in the final 4 than Alabama did How can you think that?

---

First off I don’t think that, you are just making that up (strawman gets overused but this is a text book example ) so you can dismiss the actual claim. So.....

[b]TO BE CLEAR, AGAIN I THINK THE PLAYOFFS SHOULD BE LIMITED TO THE TOP 4 CONFERENCE WINNERS[/b],

and to further be clear in the hypothetical 2017 where USCe Beats UGA and wins the SECE and goes no to upset Auburn THEY STILL wouldn’t be on my playoffs since there are still 4 teams that also won conferences and divisions ahead of them.

Even if I was just taking teams that won their division UCSe is no where close to the top 4,