quote:
No, YOU and LSU compliance don't know how to read.

I read the rules. I've practiced law for 27 years, I think I can comprehend an NCAA rule - even if it is poorly written.

But you go ahead, believe what you want. I believe what I read.

I'm gonna try this one more time. While there is a lot of overlap, an initial counter and a signer are not equivalent. There are different rules for both. Both are limited to 25 max. A signer is anyone who signs a promise of or an award of a scholarship and they count as soon as they sign and it is accepted. Even if they never show up and attend class, they still count towards the 25 signer limit (with a few exceptions and they ain't the ones you list).

Given that you know all about the initial counter exceptions, it should be clear to you that there are more signers than initial counters. This means that the signer limit will always control the max number you can sign. It's sort of like the alternative min tax; doesn't matter how many deductions you have, you owe the min.

BTW: I wouldn't mention your practice by name if this is the quality of your work.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by cfmalloy

Member since Apr 2017

97 posts

Posted on 1/23/18 at 6:14 pm to Indiana Tiger

quote:
What about JUCO Transfer QB, Malik Henry ?? by Indiana Tiger

quote:
No, YOU and LSU compliance don't know how to read.

I read the rules. I've practiced law for 27 years, I think I can comprehend an NCAA rule - even if it is poorly written.

But you go ahead, believe what you want. I believe what I read.

I'm gonna try this one more time. While there is a lot of overlap, an initial counter and a signer are not equivalent. There are different rules for both. Both are limited to 25 max. A signer is anyone who signs a promise of or an award of a scholarship and they count as soon as they sign and it is accepted. Even if they never show up and attend class, they still count towards the 25 signer limit (with a few exceptions and they ain't the ones you list).

Given that you know all about the initial counter exceptions, it should be clear to you that there are more signers than initial counters. This means that the signer limit will always control the max number you can sign. It's sort of like the alternative min tax; doesn't matter how many deductions you have, you owe the min.

BTW: I wouldn't mention your practice by name if this is the quality of your work.