re: Peyton Manning = tGOAT - Is it settled now?

quote:

---

I'd take Elway over Manning in any big game

---

I'd take:

Unitas

Bradshaw

Elway

Montana

Young

Brady

Rogers

Brees

- over Manning in a big game. He was a gaudy stat machine in his prime, but never gave the impression he could elevate the team when they really needed it.

ETA: And Rothlisberger

(Manning is the Dan Marino of his era, but was fortunate enough to get a couple of SB wins - it is what it is.)