re: Peyton Manning = tGOAT - Is it settled now?

quote:

---

It's an irrelevant stat. And after tonight, Manning's career playoff passer rating might drop BELOW Tom Brady's. Before the game Manning was sitting at 88.1 and Brady was sitting at 88.0. Manning scored a 56.6 rating this evening.

---

Of course it's irrelevant when compared to a player with 1 or 2 career playoff games, but that' isn't at all what you said. Had you said that, I would agree.

You said players play better games in their 1st playoff games, then magically get worse and the QB ratings go from high to lower. There is no basis for that, unless you have a link to some numbers on it.