re: How is Jimbo any different than Miles?

If Jimbo wouldn't be considered a homerun, I'm not sure one exists that is a viable option.

I'm not saying he'll come in and never lose a game, because nobody could do that. I just think he has the potential plus the actual on-field achievements. Herman may end up being an all-star, but when you're dropping the best we've ever had, I don't think you can go for potential alone.