re: Yearly debate for all time starting 10 (Im including a DH)

Assuming this collects all players in their prime years...

8 - Mike Trout
3 - Albert Pujols
7 - Barry Bonds
5 - Mike Schmidt
DH - Ken Griffey Jr
6 - Robin Yount
4 - Roberto Alomar
2 - Pudge Rodriguez
9 - Ichiro Suzuki

SP - Pedro Martinez

Superb mix of L/H & R/H power and speed everywhere. Superb defense as well which is why I chose someone like Ichiro over Stan Musial. Say what you want about Mike Trout, but all he needs is the longevity and sustain throughout his career. He's already had 2 seasons that are better than any season Rickey Henderson has ever had. Pedro had about a 4-5 year stretch that was as dominant as anyone in the history of the game and his pitbull attitude is contagious.