re: Would you do this trade? (Madden 25)

Depends what the rest of your LB core looks like, as well as how will your offense play out without AP.
I'd accept that trade depending on what other offers you can get, and how will he improve your defense. If you have a decent backup HB then I say deal. If not, weigh other options. I'd take Mingo based on speed alone since it's most expensive trait. You can easily upgrade block shed and that type stuff. Pretty much what I'm saying is if your linebacker core is half arse decent, I'd decline especially if Gerhart is your backup. Also weigh in cap space and how many more contract years are left. Don't trade a guy with a fresh deal for a guy.who becomes a free agent after the season. He could potentially go back to the team you got him from and all your left with is a 6th round pick and a finger in the arse