re: Would Peyton Manning or Tom Brady Receive 100% Vote from MLB Voters

quote:

---

Sure. A 100% HOF vote for any player says, to me anyway, that HE was the greatest player to ever play whichever sport. No flaws, no failings. When in fact every player fails and has a flaw in their play.

100% vote is a herd mentality. There is a reason these halls have a %, to account for dissenting voices, which should be welcomed.

Nothing in reality is 100% and players getting a post career award aren't either. Brady/Manning are first ballot HOF'ers, doesn't mean that EVERY voter thinks or should think that way. Doesn't make them any less of a great player

---

That's fricking retarded.


There are no levels of merit....each voter has a yes or no vote. The idea a voter thinks a guy is a hall of famer but won't vote for him because no one should be 100% is beyond dumb.