re: Drew Brees vs. Kurt Warner (At their Best)

quote:

---

That isn't the point....in 1999 and 2001, defenses could actually play defense. If you're going to use inflated stats from the last 3-4 years to make the argument that his peak is better, you could say multiple inferior qbs are better as well. And fwiw, I acknowledged that brees is without a doubt a better qb than Warner, I just think Warner had the better peak

---

agree with all of that

Brees clearly has the better career. Warner's peak was helped by the Rams offensive weapons but he was one of those offensive weapons.

Now if you put Warner on last year's Saints team IMO he gets destroyed/hurt instead of keeping the team near .500 (but that's a separate argument)