re: Drew Brees vs. Kurt Warner (At their Best)

quote:

---

So you don't see the flaw in comparing stats one for one during that 10 year time frame?

---

In some cases, sure. However, Warner was part of a pass happy offense unlike anything seen for the time period. I don't think it's really that far off. People claim the "Greatest Show on Turf" is the best offense of all time, and they were known for high tempo, unstoppable offense. Sounds kinda like what the Saints did in 09 and 11 to me. I think they are a pretty fair comparison, and the teams offenses are as well.


If you argue Brees playing in a different time period, and count that against his stats, you should also include the fact that Warner had a much better supporting cast.


I think Warner was phenomenal, but I just can't see the argument for him being better than Brees. Just my opinion though. I'll just respectfully disagree with you.