re: GoT S3: Episode 6 "The Climb" <<<Book Readers Thread>>> SPOILERS

That is an interesting take on Theon’s screen time. The first thing that occurs to me is that these scenes were dedicated just as much to establishing Ramsey as to building Theon’s storyline.

Because, as far as Theon’s story goes I think it’s a fascinating psychological profile of a man under that kind of inhumane treatment in the book. (You have to remember your name). But, as good as the writing and acting on this show are, I don’t really see them trying to explore those depths in significant detail.

I also don’t see Theon’s storyline as one of great redemption or progress. I think too much water has passed under the bridge. I mean he sacked Winterfell. I’m pretty sure he did at least some raiding and reaving on the coast. Even though the kids he killed were not Bran and Rickon, I don’t think anyone in the North will be likely to forgive him for that stuff. So, to that extent, the writer has a point.

But I think that Ramsey still needs to be established in all his depravity and “low cunning”. The things that will allow him to have some successes and the things that MAY come back to bite him (and through him Roose) all need to be established. Because I’m pretty sure the Bolton’s are to play a significant part in the upcoming seasons.