Again, I'll point out that some kind of logical proof needs to be shared to prove to the best of its abilities your statements. You keep assuming that your right and anyone that disagrees with you is wrong. Down South we like to call that "liberal logic"

quote:
Explain to me how the technology gives Tiger an advantage in GOAT discussions compared to Jack. Keep in mind Jack never had to play "Tiger-proofed" courses, nor did he have to deal with less skilled players in contention each week.

Review my posts on Page 11 an the beginning of Page 12. I stated clearly my views. I used multiple comparisons to widen its scope.

quote:
Explain how this contrasts my view on equipment?

I did, immediately after the post you quoted.

quote:
I think you just can't follow a conversation very well. Everything I have posted about my opinions lines up logically and doesn't contradict itself.

If you can't understand that you have been posting in circles for a day, which I just proved (with empirical evidence, mind you) in the post above this one I am responding to, you sir are the one that

quote:
can't follow a conversation very well.

2 ...

Report Post

Posted by LNCHBOX

70448

Member since Jun 2009

84304 posts

Posted on 3/12/13 at 11:18 am to unbeWEAVEable

quote:
Again, I'll point out that some kind of logical proof needs to be shared to prove to the best of its abilities your statements. You keep assuming that your right and anyone that disagrees with you is wrong. Down South we like to call that "liberal logic"

I can talk in circle too you know. How about you tell me why it's not true?

quote:
I did, immediately after the post you quoted.

No you didn't. Convince me that anything I've said contradicts myself. You can't do it. And if you try, I'll point out your comprehension error. Something is getting lost in the text if you have come to the conclusion that I've contradicted myself. I'm not Peeej, I have a functioning brain.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by LNCHBOX

70448

Member since Jun 2009

84304 posts

Posted on 3/12/13 at 11:25 am to unbeWEAVEable

quote:
All of this. And right in cue PJ gets up in here to remind us that Tiger has no one pushing him. Using this stupid logic Old Tom Morris must be the only legit golfer. He is the oldest after all.

quote:
And here we go again with another old timer. Unless I'm missing your point.

quote:
He's the biggest troll in threads like this. Or he's actually that ignorant. Either way

quote:
It never fricking fails. So when you were watching Jack in his prime, were you not infuriated by the old farts that wouldn't shut up about how so and so from 30 years ago was better? Or did that just not happen without message boards being around?

quote:
Since you're back and still harping on young guys nit seeing Jack play, answer my question from the last page.

quote:
PEDs make you putt better? Jesus you fricking moron.

quote:
You do realize the equipment Jack and co used was cutting edge for their time.too, right? Your argument is bullshite.

quote:
I don't resent it, but don't expect me to not point out the huge flaw in their line of thinking. I turn 30 next year, fwiw.

quote:
It was the best for the time period. Everyone in the field has access to the same equipment, thus the playing field is leveled for superior skill to take over.

Now if someone was trying to compare Tiger and Jack both shooting 64 in their primes on the exact same course and layout, then equipment is a factor. But for the purpose of GOAT discussions, equipment is irrelevant.

quote:
Feel free to disprove my logic.

quote:
So by this, you've just admitted that more people can win a tournament today compared to when the equipment was not as good. Which therefore makes Tiger's run more impressive.

quote:
Refute this. I don't think you can.

quote:
This too.

quote:
How does that refute my statement exactly?

quote:
What are you even talking about?

Everyone has access to the same high tech equipment for a given time period. Therefore there is no equipment advantage when comparing Tiger's run with Jack's run. Tiger uses the same equipment his competitors use, and Jack used the same equipment his competitors used.

Anyone arguing that Tiger's run is somehow diminished because of equipment advances is most likely retarded.