re: Crackpot ASOIAF Theories SPOILERS

Good question about the Weirwoods. The Andals wasted most of them, but not sure if all in the South...any evidence of them seen in Dorne at all?


I have an idea:

The more I think about it, Martin has pulled the hidden ID trick too many times if even half of our guesses are correct - most I hope turn out to be red herrings, but there's a shitload. How bout we try to count em up...include even the crackpot ones, just for shits and giggles...then we can rank them in terms of likelihood?

I'll start. We'll put the known, the obvious or most-supported near the top, crackheadpot ones at the bottom. Or 3 categories:

I. It is known (proven)

II. It is supported (popular theories here)

III. Crackstreet Gossip




I.
- Rattleshirt (re-animated)= Mance
- Catelyn Stark (re-animated) = Lady Stoneheart


II.
- R+L=J
- Gregor Clegane (re-animated) = Robert Strong
- TKotLT = Lyanna Stark
- Ashara Dayne is Septa Lemore
- Varys = Blackfyre


III.

- Tyrion = Targ (TMK + JL= Imp)
- Dayne = Mance
- CotF = The Others
- Jojen Reed = Howland Reed
- Syrio = Jaqen H'ghar
- The sailors wife = tyrions ex
- Darkstar = Real Aegon

Updated at 2:00pm, 11/16/12

This will be fun...if the gang wants to play...?