Started By
Message

re: Clemson and LSU Bands Who stole from whom?

Posted on 9/11/09 at 4:46 am to
Posted by deaconscholar
Conyers, GA
Member since Nov 2008
245 posts
Posted on 9/11/09 at 4:46 am to
I have the proof. I was in the GBFT from '62 - '67 when Bill Swor came to LSU and hired John Edmonds as the arranger. It was Edmonds and Swor who developed the pre-game show, rearranged ALL the fight songs, bought the rights and introduced "Hey Fighting Tigers" (a tune from a Broadway show) and subsequently wrote some of the finest arrangements for marching band that have ever been heard. The next time the chills run down your spine when you hear the notes of "Hold That Tiger" that starts the pre-game show, that's John Edmonds! John was not a Clemson knock-off; he hardly needed to copy anything from anybody. You'll never see John's name anywhere, at least I haven't, but he is a true hero for LSU. And perhaps I should mention that in the 60's we never heard of Clemson, or UGA for that matter. On the other hand, LSU was winning football games and so was the band. The band was selected the best college band in the nation and performed at the East=West Shrine game in San Francisco. A few years later it was voted the best in the nation by other band directors, and has consistently been regardedas the all collegebest in the SEC. Copy from Clemson? I don't think so. If you don't believe me, ask Charlie Roberts.

Posted by LSU PAINTER
Folsom
Member since Aug 2008
136 posts
Posted on 9/11/09 at 5:02 am to
WOW,
Posted by TheDoc
doc is no more
Member since Dec 2005
99297 posts
Posted on 9/11/09 at 8:28 am to
quote:

I have the proof. I was in the GBFT from '62 - '67 when Bill Swor came to LSU and hired John Edmonds as the arranger. It was Edmonds and Swor who developed the pre-game show, rearranged ALL the fight songs, bought the rights and introduced "Hey Fighting Tigers" (a tune from a Broadway show) and subsequently wrote some of the finest arrangements for marching band that have ever been heard. The next time the chills run down your spine when you hear the notes of "Hold That Tiger" that starts the pre-game show, that's John Edmonds! John was not a Clemson knock-off; he hardly needed to copy anything from anybody. You'll never see John's name anywhere, at least I haven't, but he is a true hero for LSU. And perhaps I should mention that in the 60's we never heard of Clemson, or UGA for that matter. On the other hand, LSU was winning football games and so was the band. The band was selected the best college band in the nation and performed at the East=West Shrine game in San Francisco. A few years later it was voted the best in the nation by other band directors, and has consistently been regardedas the all collegebest in the SEC. Copy from Clemson? I don't think so. If you don't believe me, ask Charlie Roberts.


BOOM #3
Posted by Tiger TBone
Alpharetta Ga.
Member since Jul 2008
173 posts
Posted on 9/12/09 at 7:17 am to
quote:

I have the proof. I was in the GBFT from '62 - '67 when Bill Swor came to LSU and hired John Edmonds as the arranger. It was Edmonds and Swor who developed the pre-game show, rearranged ALL the fight songs, bought the rights and introduced "Hey Fighting Tigers" (a tune from a Broadway show) and subsequently wrote some of the finest arrangements for marching band that have ever been heard. The next time the chills run down your spine when you hear the notes of "Hold That Tiger" that starts the pre-game show, that's John Edmonds! John was not a Clemson knock-off; he hardly needed to copy anything from anybody. You'll never see John's name anywhere, at least I haven't, but he is a true hero for LSU.

Spot on, Deacon. I came into the band in 1971 and had a lot to live up to. Dr. William F. Swor was the Bear Bryant of college marching band directors, no question. He married both the military precision with the "Show Band of the South" heritage of Carazo and Long into something wonderfully innovative.

Drop me an email at mike.a.tiger@gmail.com, I'd like to exchange more with you. Edmunds will be mentioned in the band bio that will appear soon in the Galleries Musique section of the La. Music Hall of Fame. You and I share a piece of membership in the LMHOF now as the Tiger Band becomes the first college band to be honored in a hall of fame. LMHOF.org - Louisiana Music Hall of Fame
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram