120 is considered surefire PB, All-Pro territory. 130 is considered All-Pro, MVP level, great tier throughout history. Anything over 140 is considered an all-time elite season (think if it like a 2,000 yard rushing season equivalent for passers).

There are a couple of outliers in there that scored highly, but were due to highly efficient but extremely limited usage (Nic Foles 2013 and Purdy 2023) so I won’t say it is 100% perfect and don’t question it - I personally have some issues with the formula that is used to calculate Passer Rating in general - but it’s pretty much the best way to compare how great of a passer a quarterback was compared to his peers across the years. It doesn’t factor in what a quarterback does in the running game so guys like Mahomes, Young, Rodgers, and Jackson are not rewarded for their full impact as a player though.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by shel311

McKinney, Texas

Member since Aug 2004

111290 posts

Posted on 2/13/24 at 12:36 pm to Dairy Sanders

quote:
120 is considered surefire PB, All-Pro territory. 130 is considered All-Pro, MVP level, great tier throughout history

So you'd agree based on your original post specific to "elite" play that 130 is better than 120, right?

120 is Pro Bowl caliber, but we know with certainly that just being a Pro Bowler does not make you elite.

You said 130 is considered All-Pro, MVP level...THAT is elite.

So using 130 or higher as the barometer:

Brady - 3 times in his 21 full seasons played, or 14.3% of the time
Peyton - 2 times in his 17 full seasons played, or 11.8% of the time

1 ...

Report Post

More Sports - Replies to Post

Return To Board

Page 1

Return To Board