p226: No I don't know anything about you are 100% correct. So let me correct my earlier post and let me specify that I am talking about your football analysis here only and your post made in a public football forum. So related to your football analysis relative to LSU's roster, it is my belief you are incorrect.

Lets look at the numbers in more detail:

One correction, 29 portal guys for 2022 and 2023 combined and 26 HS signees for 2023 and 15 in 2022. So that is a total of 70 guys BK has brought in.

O's 2020 and 2021 classes left very little on the roster. That is the reason for the 29 portal guys and awarding scholarships to preferred walk-ons to fill out the roster.

So again, just you try doing some basic addition. From the 2020 Coach O recruiting class, only 2 guys are left (Martinez, Guillory) . Boutte, Roy an Ojulari played last year. So 5 of the 22 HS signees from Coach O's 2020 class played in 2022 and 2023 (This year). That class was a bust basically. The 2021 class is better to be fair as 14 of the 24 HS signees plus Major Burns who was brought in are still here. The other 3 guys did not pan out (Jones from Clemson was a transfer in that group). But that is 16 guys who are JRs, RS JRs or SR's out of a possible 47 that are still around from O's last 2 classes. That is not enough from those 2 classes. Those are just the facts.

And if you look at the players, they are some obvious super talented WR's (Malik, BTJR, Hilton) and 1 excellent OL in Dellenger (2 backup guys in Martinez and Makaneole) but no elite DB's in that bunch. No TE's at all, no elite RB's, 1 solid LB in PENN III. Nuss was in that class so we will see how he turns out.

So of the 80 players that were evaluated as part of LSU's 247 Composite talent ranking, only 16 of those are from O's last 2 classes (only 19 were around when BK got here for 2022). That is it.

So now you take a look at what I wrote and you tell me what does not make sense.

This post was edited on 11/27/23 at 1:26 pm