Started By
Message

re: Dianna Russini reporting there is a team "waiting in the wings" on CSP ready to swoop in

Posted on 1/24/23 at 1:42 pm to
Posted by ghost2most
Member since Mar 2012
6690 posts
Posted on 1/24/23 at 1:42 pm to
Serious question. Is Payton that much better than McCarthy?

He has a slightly better career win %. And basically the same post season record.

McCarthy has the same number of SBs and more NFCG appearances.
Posted by BigTigerJoe
Member since Aug 2022
5855 posts
Posted on 1/24/23 at 2:01 pm to
quote:

Serious question. Is Payton that much better than McCarthy?

He has a slightly better career win %. And basically the same post season record.

McCarthy has the same number of SBs and more NFCG appearances.


Remove this one play and Payton has two more playoff wins and an additional Superbowl victory potentially:



He is the better coach. There were other suspect officiating in other playoff games as well.
Posted by Weekend Warrior79
Member since Aug 2014
16496 posts
Posted on 1/24/23 at 2:05 pm to
IMO, it would be really hard to say until Payton goes to another team and we see what kind of success he can have/sustain. All success from Payton is matched with Brees, so the question will always loom about "who made who?" until Payton shows he can do it without Brees

Also, look at the teams both got their start with. Payton came in and quickly rebuilt a franchise with a history of being terrible. He then took them to the next level. McCarthy took over a historically good team, coming off of a bad year, with a lot of great pieces in place.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram