re: UPDATE: Idaho Murders Thread (Links inside)

I have always thought that Maddie was his target or Maddie and Xana. And i still kind of do. But my next theory of why that night throws my theory of Maddie and Xana being the targets out the window.

So Just a theory to toss around:
So why THAT night? With Ethan there? Ethan’s jeep was in the front of the house. He had to have known Ethan was there since he’d been watching them & the house. & why was he driving around so stupidly before the crime increasing his chances of getting caught (building up the nerve debating on whether or not to go in with Ethan there??) and going to Albertsons THAT night— again increasing his chances of getting caught. (getting last minute supplies)

It all seems very rushed and not well planned like you’d expect for someone in his field of study.

maybe I’m late figuring this out, but i think bryan chose that night because it was kaylee’s last night there. She was was moving to Austin. She had already moved out, but went back to Moscow one last time to show Maddie her new Range Rover.

He didn’t expect this. When he saw the iconic post of all of them at the house WITH Kaylee on instagram he likely thought oh she’s back so now i can kill Maddie Xana AND Kaylee?? this is my last chance b4 Kaylee is gone for good.

was Kaylee the only target? Maddie, Xana and Ethan got in the way? Or were Maddie and Kaylee the targets and Xana and Ethan got in the way? Or were Maddie, Xana and Kaylee all targets? Or were all 4 targets??

Anyway, this is the first time i ever thought about why he chose that night. It was his last chance to eliminate Kaylee. I hate typing that :(
But that night in his mind he thought now or never. It WASN’T well planned. She was graduating early. THAT caught him off guard.
Just a theory….

But I’m still leaning towards the theory that Maddie and Xana were his only targets so the Kaylee back one last night theory doesn’t jive with the Maddie and Xana were his targets theory : /