Favorite team:
Location:Westchester, NY
Biography:
Interests:GoT, WD, geek stuff
Occupation:
Number of Posts:38
Registered on:4/16/2013
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
[quote]I think the show is easier to theorize to. There is not a lot of detail that has to be read and the POV's are closer together. Subtle hints are harder to see in books rather than shows. I know all readers will accidently skip some parts or just look over them. Show watchers are attuned to the...
[quote]Giant thread talking about Tyrion as a Targaryen[/quote] Interesting. Don't know that I buy it. But interesting. A funny thing here is that when I first saw the theory offered, and saw the word "Targ", my mind registered "Warg" and that's what REALLY threw me! lol and then the talk o...
What's all this "Tyrion is a Targ" stuff? I've never heard this theory. what's the basis? We've never seen anything suggesting that in the Tyrion POV chapters, have we? ...
[quote]this, i think [/quote] Cool. Thanks, manwich....
[quote]5 is concurrent with 4 so TV season 4 will have bits from three different books[/quote] Right. But I was wondering if any of the Harpy stuff was in book *3*. I'm thinking not - perhaps we first hear about it at the start of book 5? ...
I thought it was a very decent finale. some thoughts.. - I didn't have anywhere as big a problem w/the Dany crowd mosh ending. Yes, a little cheesy, but they just showed the Lannisters basically conquering Westeros, so they ended with a counterpoint: Dany's rising star. which is the directions...
[quote]I am still think that they show some of the book 4 story lines next season. They don't need 10 episodes to finish the book but i also ate some crow pie cause of np PW. [/quote] I was just trying to think if there's enough of Book 3 left to fill up s4, or if we'll definitely get a good chun...
[quote]Because I'm assuming she didn't know Arya was in the last episode. I don't think Mel is referencing a future mistaken vision when talking to a little girl.[/quote] She would know who Arya was if she saw her in a vision. I forget - when she sees "Arya" in her vision and tells Jon about i...
[quote]I don't think so. [/quote] Why not? do you have some info to the contrary? Assuming they follow the book, we know she will see someone she thinks to be Arya meeting her in the future....
[quote]So I've been thinking about this a lot: Mel telling Arya that "We will meet again" is quite possibly a spoiler for a future scene in the books (although, in the books, they will be meeting for the first time). It would be based on plot details that GRRM has told the producers. So...do y...
what "deductions" were madein the non-readers thread?...
ah...good points, Dire Wolf - I'd forgotten that stuff. Altho I guess a prior assassination attempt by Joffrey might seal the deal. Perhaps they will cut out some of that other stuff on the show, so they needed some extra "evidence" against Tyrion....
[quote]I think cersei is full of shite. Maybe that fake info will be used against him after the purple wedding. [/quote] OTOH, that might explain why Tyrion was the main suspect in the death of Joffrey. So perhaps that's where they're going with that. I forget why he was suspected in the book....
I apologize if this was mentioned in the previous 27 pages of post (yikes!), but I had a question about the revelation that Joffery, not Cersei, ordered Tyrion dead during the battle of Blackwater. Is that the way it was in the books? That was not my recollection. I had thought that it was Cersei...
The Bobby Riggs episode is my favorite! "First he underestimated women, and then he underestimated Ungers!" "History was rewritten by Oscar Madisoy, who cast his best friend into slavery!"...
[quote]It wouldn't be completely cut, just scaled down a lot to where it's not the full wedding. this way, they could not worry about a ton of extras and decorations. a small celebration for RW or something, idk. smae shite still happens, just much smaller of a scale[/quote] I agree- they could d...
[quote] -What have you got under leaky pipes? -Puddles. [/quote] Youse'll be back on yer knees begging me for a spot...just like my mom was!! Odd Couple is the all time greatest comedy in the history of TV....

re: Best explaination of TDKR

Posted by ctowner1 on 4/19/13 at 3:38 pm
Avengers was a fun movie top to bottom. It made me happy that I lived long enough to see such a cool translation of comics into live action film. It was funny. It was exciting. It was cool to watch. Is it a deep sophisticated movie with powerful themes? Nope. But its a nonstop fun ride. TDK...
[quote] Game of Thrones Season 3 E3 - Walk of Punishment <Book Readers thread>*spoilers* Reading all of this affirms that I think GRRM is never going to finish this series .[/quote] that would suck if he does not. :^(...