Favorite team:LSU 
Location:Montgomery, AL
Biography:Played tuba in Tiger Band 85-89
Interests:
Occupation:Air Force Retired
Number of Posts:2503
Registered on:5/31/2008
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message

re: Anybody deal with sleep walking?

Posted by Thorny on 11/20/26 at 5:59 pm to
I used to do it in high school. I stopped sometime in college.

Once on a youth group trip, I ended up waking up in a friend's room. I quietly went back to my own, hoping he didn't know. When he asked me about it, I said, "I don't know what you are talking about."

Then two girls on the trip with us sat down and asked me, "What were you doing in our room last night?"

Busted, I fessed up. I don't remember being in their room at all.

re: LSU President says no RJ Luis

Posted by Thorny on 11/20/26 at 5:29 pm to
I'm not giving Tom Mars the time of day.

Just because the SEC bylaws say what he is saying doesn't automatically mean it would hold up in court if the SEC tried to argue that an actual vote to kick LSU out happened over this.

re: LSU President says no RJ Luis

Posted by Thorny on 11/20/26 at 4:49 pm to
quote:

The SEC put out a letter from their own legal team that clearly stated that they would not penalize LSU for playing Luis, and then threatened to expel LSU two days later for doing what they said was okay. They also have a double standard when it comes to LSU because they have never threatened any other member schools with expulsion for rostering players in a similar circumstance.


I am literally in Twitter spats today with fans of other schools who are making the argument that "it's LSU's fault that they took the SEC at it's word."

re: Why did LSU remove RJ Luis?

Posted by Thorny on 11/20/26 at 3:08 pm to
quote:

The conjecture in the article posted is that LSU leadership thought there was no chance of other members voting for simple expulsion and then found out there was.



This is probably right, but it does not explain why the SEC lead counsel sent the email. Seems like he should have not done so until that possibility was at least considered. More incompetence by the SEC headquarters.
quote:

The deal cut yesterday required Luis’ contempt charge to be immediately dropped yesterday and it was. Who else would file a contempt charge? LSU surely will not. There has to be more to this story and is being orchestrated.


I can understand this, but I don't understand why the SEC dropping its federal court case would be part of that agreement.
quote:

He left after after 3 years at St Johns.

Was not good enough or developed to succeed in the NBA. He was undrafted and still tried to push on.

Well after little to no instant success he said well look everyone is getting these injunctions. Why don't I try and go back to college. Make some money and find a judge who will rule in my favor.

Then you have him committing to wade in May. I am in favor of a guy coming back if he did his four years and then is a candidate for 5 for 5.

The football players have a better case than Luis.


All of this is true. That's why I sensed a trap when the SEC counsel sent his email to Clayton.

That said, none of those distinctions have found sympathy in a court of law yet. Yes, Charles Bediako eventually lost his TRO against the NCAA and Bama de-rostered him. However, many players with G-League time are playing college basketball today. Additionally, Oklahoma is in the SEC and has a player who signed a contract and participated in the NBA Summer League.

Why should LSU and Will Wade not pursue playing Luis if there are plenty of precedents in the NCAA and SEC that show one he got a TRO, he could play?

I'm fine with Luis being ineligible. It doesn't surprise me at all. However, no court has said he isn't. He's just tired of fighting the two-faced SEC over the point.

JMHO.

GEAUX TIGERS!

re: “Homeowners becoming their parents”

Posted by Thorny on 11/18/26 at 3:54 pm to
I completely relate to the guy trying to figure out the remote in the TV streaming one.

re: Lawsuit update?

Posted by Thorny on 11/18/26 at 3:38 pm to
quote:

A) hire a guy who the league thinks doesn't follow the rules Who was never threatened with suspension or other penalties at Ole Miss.
B) then you hire another coach who was chased out for not following the rules After he had completed his show-cause with the NCAA, like Auburn hiring Bruce Pearl
C) conspire with players to contest the ability of the league to enforce their rules in court and get into a PR campaign attacking the league You have evidence of this conspiring at LSU, but not at Ole Miss (Chambliss), Texas (Hutson), etc.?
D) then you double down in basketball using the same tactics after a rule is passed specifically prohibiting that With the exception of Luis, every LSU basketball player's eligibility question has direct parallels in other schools in every conference, and do not involve the NBA or G-League specified in the SEC rule. As for Luis, the SEC lawyers granted permission for LSU to proceed.

quote:

The rule in question does apply to Luis because he was rostered after it was passed. He does not meet the criteria for eligibility and as a result LSU faces whatever sanctions the league chooses to apply for being rostered and potentially playing.


Not according to the SEC lawyers quoted in multiple articles and the letter the LSU counsel sent to the SEC, who say they will comply with the most recent order.

I get why Luis shouldn't be rostered. I'm surprised he's winning this case in the wake of Bediako. But, he is getting injunctions granted.

I don't know how you get to decide which injunction to follow and which to ignore.

re: Lawsuit update?

Posted by Thorny on 11/18/26 at 3:09 pm to
quote:

Their decision makers went rogue when they hired Kiffin,


So you admit, this is about the hiring of Kiffin, not about what he may or may not have done.

So, why was the hiring of Kiffin so egregious compared to other hires? Was Florida going rogue when they hired Sumrall on the same day?

I didn't think Kiffin would come to LSU because Ole Miss was in the playoff. But, there is no rule over it, and the NCAA schedule of having early signing day essentially meant LSU couldn't wait. Would LSU have been rogue had we hired a coordinator from a playoff team and demand they be full time and not coach for their playoff team?

Or is all of this a joining of LSU and Kiffin that can't be allowed?

quote:


Good, then we get a forfeit win over each of those schools.


Look, this thing is getting out of hand, I agree.

But this past weekend shows that the SEC maintains the right to declare who and who would be the forfeiting team in such cases. Just ask Oklahoma.

GEAUX TIGERS!

re: Federal Court - LSU vs SEC

Posted by Thorny on 11/18/26 at 11:54 am to
quote:


Appears to be real


This is just a guy reposting the Tweet. It doesn't mean confirmation of anything that actually happened in the court.

Not that I'm saying the original Tweet is wrong. Just that this isn't confirmation that it is right.
It means that Luis can play free of NCAA interference under the Preliminary Injunctions he was given back in August and last week. As I understand it, he still has a trial date in the future, but it is after the season.

It is not related to today's federal hearing, which involves the SEC.

re: Federal Court - LSU vs SEC

Posted by Thorny on 11/18/26 at 10:31 am to
quote:

How can you claim LSU violates your right to free association when you have the power to throw it out of the conference?


I think the SEC sees itself as the future of college sports governance, and thus wants to hold the power to decide who fits at the top "superconference" level without incurring potential damages for schools they leave out.

They may not want to really kick LSU out, but they want to be able to eat another conference, like the BigXII, without having to pay off Cincinnati when they decide to not include them in the merger.

I think this is a ridiculous argument, as many have pointed out that there are massive TV deals involved. Letting a school go without cause or compensation should never be just waived off with a court precedent like this.

This should get kicked out today, as all of LSU's points are strong, IMHO.
quote:

The football players went the pro route because they were told and or thought their eligibility was officially over, Louis, on the other hand, left as a junior and voluntarily gave up his eligibility

This makes it worse for Luis


Which is why so many of us didn't like the way we went after Luis. We thought he would lose his injunction as the legal case moves forward. But, we were wrong.
quote:

Not quite LSU-Auburn 2006, but close


Earlier in that game, LSU had an interception overturned under the exact same situation.

We remember because we were the victim.

GEAUX TIGERS!

re: Sam Leavitt not singing Alma Mater

Posted by Thorny on 11/17/26 at 4:32 pm to
Fair.

Back in the 80s when I was in Tiger Band, we never played it after games. It was "Fight for LSU," followed by the music from the halftime show, and then in 1988 or so, finishing up with "Let Us Break Bread Together." Then get down to the gate and line up. Didn't even sing it before leaving the stadium like they do now.

Like I said, it would be great for college football to have some honor, but trying to create something like that would be impossible these days.

GEAUX TIGERS!
quote:

I wouldn't bet on it. He could be quoting the words from Luis' attorney letter he received.


That would be a stupid thing to do, and the LSU lawyers have not been stupid throughout this whole saga.

I guess we will find out.
With all the news yesterday about the SEC backing off the Luis case being solely based on a statement from Luis' lawyer, I was hesitant to roster Luis. I specifically stated that LSU had better hear it directly from the SEC.

With this decision, I'm confident that Rousse has received those assurances from the SEC. Since he is a named defendant in the federal lawsuit, I seriously doubt he didn't consult the university and state lawyers before allowing this. I fully expect that if the SEC lawyers try to bring this up in oral arguments tomorrow, the LSU lawyers will have receipts to slap them down.

I hope he is right.

BOOT UP!!!

re: Sam Leavitt not singing Alma Mater

Posted by Thorny on 11/17/26 at 3:53 pm to
As a former member of Tiger Band and father of a graduate of the Naval Academy, I would love for every school to have the "sing second" ethic of the service academies. Win, go stand for the loser's alma mater, then sing your own with your vanquished opponents behind you. There is an honor to this and it would be good for college football overall. It's such a good tradition that the opponents of Army, Navy, and Air Force do this when playing them (as I understand it, LSU did it when Army played in Tiger Stadium.) It was also cool to see it in the 2015 game against South Carolina that was moved to Tiger Stadium, as a nod to those in Columbia SC that had been affected by the flooding.

But, that's not reality. Singing the Alma Mater is a recent development that happened many years after I left college and Tiger Band. I love it, but I'm not going to get bent out of shape when a player may not think much of it. Of all the things wrong with this team and college football overall, this isn't that big a deal. JMHO.

GEAUX TIGERS!!
quote:

when the play on the field is easily fixable.

Then why hasn't it been fixed?


I think it is fair to ask that question, but remember this as well: teams that rely heavily on the portal are going to be a bit of feast or famine.

We got Leavitt this year. He was very highly recruited but has a major hole in his game. Take that hole away, this LSU team is at least 8-2 at this point, and may even be 10-0. Was that hole identified before everyone recruited him? Are you sure that if we had gotten Austin Simmons instead that he would not have turned over the ball? His Mizzou team isn't any better on the record books.

If he continues to rely on the portal, Kiffin will need to have years where he wins those types of games, but don't be surprised when we go through a feast-or-famine type cycle. After all, that seems to be the situation on the diamond with Jay.

GEAUX TIGERS!