Favorite team:LSU 
Location:Texas
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:12145
Registered on:4/25/2004
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
Fair enough. If my front yard in Mississippi starts sounding like Manhattan, can I list the place at Manhattan prices too? :lol:
quote:

70 dB Sounds • Appliances: Vacuum cleaner, washing machine, dishwasher, or a coffee grinder. • Environment: A lively restaurant, a busy office, or moderate background noise in a coffee shop. • Transit: A passenger car traveling at 60 mph heard from inside or nearby


The comparison to vacuums helps me picture it. I’d want to know where he took that reading and whether the sound quits when the construction crew goes home. I run my vacuum for twenty minutes and that's one thing. If I could hear my neighbor’s from my bedroom all night, I’d have a different opinion of the same sound. Anybody know which it is here?

re: Patriots in control

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/18/26 at 8:58 pm to
yeah, this thread went ~60 posts before we tracked down that this was slop.
Also seasonal. Does this every late fall and hits a low around Christmas.

re: Patriots in control

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/18/26 at 5:46 pm to
It's easy to get got.

But it also says something about what we consider plausible enough to be coming from the POTUS that nobody has challenged the authenticity for pages.

You kept asking and asking. Nobody had answers, but it must have seemed plausible.

I think feeling puzzled feels normal now.

re: Patriots in control

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/18/26 at 5:26 pm to
On which account or site?

I see this version on the White House X account on Nov. 10:



LINK

re: Patriots in control

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/18/26 at 2:40 pm to
wow. that's grim.

Let's get a patriot gif for old times sake.

re: US loses measles elimination status

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/18/26 at 10:37 am to
I think that happened for some people. I also take your point about "comms". If you think Fauci used his authority badly, calling it bad messaging sounds like a better choice of words would've fixed it but you're criticism was broader than that and I was being a little glib since you were. I can see why that would make somebody give RFK Jr. a hearing they wouldn't have before. Where I'd want to know more is why RFK in particular. There were a lot of critics of Fauci and the US public health COVID response. What did people see him get right that made them more willing to trust his judgement on the next thing?

re: US loses measles elimination status

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/18/26 at 10:03 am to
I think the standards you need for Fauci should be pretty similar to for RFK (they're not in the same exact position, so not exactly).

re: US loses measles elimination status

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/18/26 at 9:20 am to
A great example of bad public science leader comms that probably also has consequences.

re: US loses measles elimination status

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/18/26 at 9:18 am to
That’s fair. Some of those communities had low vaccination rates long before he took office. I don’t know how many people who got sick would’ve gotten vaccinated if Kennedy had said something different, and you can’t pin particular deaths on him.

What I do think he owns is the advice he gave, though. During the Texas outbreak he told parents the MMR vaccine causes deaths every year. If you’re trying to get a hesitant parent to vaccinate a kid who’s still susceptible, I think that makes a doc’s job harder. I’m glad he’s recommending MMR now, though. It’s the word “continuing” I take issue within his most recent statement because parents who listened to him both times are hearing a mixed message.

re: US loses measles elimination status

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/18/26 at 9:10 am to
Fair question, and I should’ve said “should” there. A health secretary making a claim about vaccine deaths ought to be able to tell us what evidence supports it. On this one, the paper counted deaths reported after vaccination and the authors themselves say their data can’t establish what caused them. Is there other evidence behind Kennedy’s claim that the vaccine causes deaths every year? That’s what would make it more defensible.
He called it propaganda that the mmr is an effective/safe vaccine and that getting it is largely unnecessary. He's recommending it now, though, and trying to emphasize that he's "continuing to do so". Since we started getting measles deaths again, he's dialed himself back.

re: US loses measles elimination status

Posted by TigerDoc on 11/17/26 at 10:35 pm to
The authors were a red flag for me too, but the stronger point is that even taking their analysis at face value, it doesn’t establish what he’s claiming. That’s a check we can apply regardless of whose names are on it (after all, those authors carry respect in some anti-establishment circles).
That paper says its data can't establish the causality. It counts deaths reported after vaccination, which isn’t the same as showing the vaccine caused them. Those reports deserve investigation, but they don’t establish the annual death claim. Public officials usually rely on science that draws firmer conclusions than that for such consequential guidance (e.g. with vaccines causing immunity and we can get into the evidence of that if you'd like).

As for splitting MMR, my point was about suggesting the existing vaccine is unsafe. What evidence shows that separating its three components would improve safety? He tried to get rid of the mandate without giving families the prospect of an available safe alternative and the disease can be deadly and disabling.
He claimed MMR was killing multiple people annually. He also suggested that MMR should be broken up into multiple vaccines implying the current version isn't safe. Now did that cause people to not get vaccinated? :dunno: But it can't have helped the problem which just continues to worse, or at least it has. Maybe endemic status will prompt more people to vaccinate.
yeah, they can trace cases back to geographical origins and that's what they've done for some previous small outbreaks, but they're finding it sufficient cases now without travel contacts that they're saying it's got a large enough pool of hosts here to keep generating illness just from people living here (and that's not something that's been the case since the 90's).
yeah, I think we agree on what should drive the decision, but “the track record is excellent” is itself something most people know by trusting other people, notably their doctor with the variety of institutions that stands behind his/her credibility. Once that trust takes a hit, they don’t necessarily know where the doubt should stop as I've noticed on vaccine threads. That doesn’t make rejecting MMR sound, but it helps explain why it happens, which is a major thing people are trying to sort out ITT.