- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Score Board
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- SEC Score Board
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
GurleyGirl
| Favorite team: | Georgia |
| Location: | Georgia |
| Biography: | UGA alumus |
| Interests: | |
| Occupation: | Retired |
| Number of Posts: | 14386 |
| Registered on: | 11/5/2015 |
| Online Status: | Online |
Recent Posts
Message
re: What was the stupidest thing about final seasons of GOT?
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/22/25 at 6:41 am to Frac the world
I stopped watching after season 5. Up to that point the show was pretty consistent with the books and was good. Thereafter, the show writers started winging it and the show was inconsistent with the plot established in the books and became ridiculously bad.
The situation reminded me of LOST to some extent in which the writing directionally became the antithesis of the expectations of the fans.
Copilot described it as such:
===========================================
Most fans agree the writing in Game of Thrones took a sharp downturn starting in Season 7, and by Season 8 it was widely considered “ridiculously bad.” The decline is tied to the show outpacing George R.R. Martin’s books, forcing the showrunners to rely on outlines rather than detailed source material.
?? When the Decline Happened
• Seasons 1–4: Strong writing, bolstered by George R.R. Martin’s direct involvement. He personally wrote standout episodes like Blackwater (S2) and The Lion and the Rose (S4).
• Season 5: Still close to the books, though cracks began to show. This was the last season that largely followed Martin’s published material.
• Season 6: Mixed reception. Some praised big moments (Battle of the Bastards), but others noticed rushed plots and weaker character arcs.
• Seasons 7–8: Universally criticized. Plotlines became compressed, character decisions felt unearned, and spectacle replaced nuanced storytelling. The finale in particular is often cited as one of TV’s most disappointing endings.
?? Why the Writing Fell Apart
• Outpaced the Books: Martin hadn’t finished The Winds of Winter or A Dream of Spring. The showrunners had only broad outlines of his intended endgame.
• Shift in Focus: Dialogue-heavy political intrigue gave way to fast-moving battles and visual spectacle. Quantitative analysis even shows dialogue density plummeted from ~70 words per minute in Season 1 to just 10 in the final season.
• Compressed Timelines: Seasons 7 and 8 were shorter (7 and 6 episodes respectively), forcing rushed resolutions to sprawling storylines.
• Character Arcs Undermined: Beloved characters like Daenerys and Jaime were given abrupt, inconsistent endings that felt disconnected from years of buildup.
?? The Fan Consensus
• Season 5: Last season with consistent quality.
• Season 6: Transitional, with both highs and lows.
• Season 7–8: Where writing is widely considered “ridiculously bad,” culminating in the divisive finale.
In short: Game of Thrones maintained strong writing through Season 5, began wobbling in Season 6, and collapsed in Seasons 7 and 8 when spectacle overtook storytelling and the show had to invent its own endgame.
The situation reminded me of LOST to some extent in which the writing directionally became the antithesis of the expectations of the fans.
Copilot described it as such:
===========================================
Most fans agree the writing in Game of Thrones took a sharp downturn starting in Season 7, and by Season 8 it was widely considered “ridiculously bad.” The decline is tied to the show outpacing George R.R. Martin’s books, forcing the showrunners to rely on outlines rather than detailed source material.
?? When the Decline Happened
• Seasons 1–4: Strong writing, bolstered by George R.R. Martin’s direct involvement. He personally wrote standout episodes like Blackwater (S2) and The Lion and the Rose (S4).
• Season 5: Still close to the books, though cracks began to show. This was the last season that largely followed Martin’s published material.
• Season 6: Mixed reception. Some praised big moments (Battle of the Bastards), but others noticed rushed plots and weaker character arcs.
• Seasons 7–8: Universally criticized. Plotlines became compressed, character decisions felt unearned, and spectacle replaced nuanced storytelling. The finale in particular is often cited as one of TV’s most disappointing endings.
?? Why the Writing Fell Apart
• Outpaced the Books: Martin hadn’t finished The Winds of Winter or A Dream of Spring. The showrunners had only broad outlines of his intended endgame.
• Shift in Focus: Dialogue-heavy political intrigue gave way to fast-moving battles and visual spectacle. Quantitative analysis even shows dialogue density plummeted from ~70 words per minute in Season 1 to just 10 in the final season.
• Compressed Timelines: Seasons 7 and 8 were shorter (7 and 6 episodes respectively), forcing rushed resolutions to sprawling storylines.
• Character Arcs Undermined: Beloved characters like Daenerys and Jaime were given abrupt, inconsistent endings that felt disconnected from years of buildup.
?? The Fan Consensus
• Season 5: Last season with consistent quality.
• Season 6: Transitional, with both highs and lows.
• Season 7–8: Where writing is widely considered “ridiculously bad,” culminating in the divisive finale.
In short: Game of Thrones maintained strong writing through Season 5, began wobbling in Season 6, and collapsed in Seasons 7 and 8 when spectacle overtook storytelling and the show had to invent its own endgame.
re: Kiffin family reported looking
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/18/25 at 6:44 am to PCDAWG
As I said on the Rant, he's taking his visits just like any top recruit and will make a decision that is in the best interests of his career and his family.
re: Rooting for Texas against Texas A&M or not?
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/18/25 at 6:42 am to Violent Hip Swivel
I want us to win the SECCG again and the NCG again fortifying our place as the best team in college football having won 3 out of the last 5 NC's. :nana:
re: If you are a coach and your only goal is a NC, do you choose LSU, UF, or Texas?
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/18/25 at 6:36 am to 308
In today's climate, i would chose Texas for the strongest recruiting base and seemingly unlimited resources.
Plus it's a much nicer and safer environment for my family at a high quality university.
Plus it's a much nicer and safer environment for my family at a high quality university.
re: Bama/UGA versus OU/Texas
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/18/25 at 6:30 am to UncleRoll
I don't agree with your premise.
There's a pattern to be sure but "can't" is unproven over time.
And the fact that there are many strong teams in the conference as opposed to 1 or 2 makes for a stronger overall conference which has been supported by how well SEC teams perform in bowl games.
There's a pattern to be sure but "can't" is unproven over time.
And the fact that there are many strong teams in the conference as opposed to 1 or 2 makes for a stronger overall conference which has been supported by how well SEC teams perform in bowl games.
re: I'm going to laugh my arse off if he stays
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/18/25 at 6:23 am to Landmass
He's obviously doing what top recruits do: making his visits to check out facilities and options and then he will make decision that is the best interests of him and his family.
Seems reasonable to me.
Seems reasonable to me.
re: Penalties
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/17/25 at 8:57 am to hookem33
We had the same issue when Mark Richt was our coach. Richt's philosophy, which I didn't agree with, is allowing your players to play aggressively is going to incur an acceptable level of penalties.
What this really means is lack of discipline which creates negative team issues far beyond excessive penalties.
What this really means is lack of discipline which creates negative team issues far beyond excessive penalties.
re: We just aren’t that good
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/16/25 at 8:22 pm to VYForever
Texas has an expensive talented team.
The main issue seems to be coaching.
The main issue seems to be coaching.
re: Georgia SEC Championship and Playoff Rankings
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/16/25 at 1:26 pm to GamerAg
quote:
If Ags and Tide win out and Bama wins SECCG, UGA will be 5 at best
Probably true but A&M has the more balanced team and I'm expecting them to win. Either way, if we win out, we will be in the playoffs one way or another.
re: TX Player: "It's not like [it was]the big bad Georgia Bulldogs, it was, we hurt ourselves"
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/16/25 at 1:22 pm to UTprideofTX
Texas has one of the most expensive teams in college football; they have very good players.
But they don't seem to be well coached.
And yea, they had a lot of penalties but they were the most penalized team in college football this season so that was nothing new.
I was surprised by all the drops. And if those had been caught it might have made a 2 TD difference but not a 25 point difference.
But they don't seem to be well coached.
And yea, they had a lot of penalties but they were the most penalized team in college football this season so that was nothing new.
I was surprised by all the drops. And if those had been caught it might have made a 2 TD difference but not a 25 point difference.
re: Who hires Mike Bobo
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/16/25 at 11:24 am to AwgustaDawg
No one. Bobo is Kirby's best friend and happy where he is with his son playing Center.
re: Some thoughts on next game
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/14/25 at 7:41 am to PCDAWG
Texas has one of the best teams money can buy.
They definitely have as much talent as we are do and are better at some positions.
As such I am expecting another close game; another OT nailbiter would not surprise me.
I'm concerned that Texas will control the line of scrimmage on both sides of the ball. I'm hoping our depth will pull us through in the 2nd half as it has in previous games.
Their defense is probably better than our defense overall so it will take innovative play calling and excellent execution to get first downs and keep their offense off the field.
Manning is developing and our secondary will be challenged to cover their talented receivers.
But I am actually more concerned that they will be able to run the ball and set up play action down field on our vulnerable secondary.
I think we will have to load the box to stop their running game and hopefully some creative blitzing can put some pressure on Manning.
We can't let him get outside where he can pick up key yards with his legs and buy time to improvise down-field.
They definitely have as much talent as we are do and are better at some positions.
As such I am expecting another close game; another OT nailbiter would not surprise me.
I'm concerned that Texas will control the line of scrimmage on both sides of the ball. I'm hoping our depth will pull us through in the 2nd half as it has in previous games.
Their defense is probably better than our defense overall so it will take innovative play calling and excellent execution to get first downs and keep their offense off the field.
Manning is developing and our secondary will be challenged to cover their talented receivers.
But I am actually more concerned that they will be able to run the ball and set up play action down field on our vulnerable secondary.
I think we will have to load the box to stop their running game and hopefully some creative blitzing can put some pressure on Manning.
We can't let him get outside where he can pick up key yards with his legs and buy time to improvise down-field.
re: Ole Miss = Sabotaged
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/14/25 at 7:03 am to FAT SEXY
I feel badly for Ole Miss.
If Kiffin does take the Florida job he will have fortified his image as a gun for hire with no loyalty.
He has already undermined this season for Ole Miss by not signing a contract extension which I'm sure could be leveraged by the Florida offer.
But in the end he might feel he has a better chance at a NC at proven winner like Florida. He is somewhat similar to Steve Spurrier in personality. :lol:
But from my perspective his legacy could be improved considerably by winning a NC at a dark-horse like Ole Miss.
If Kiffin does take the Florida job he will have fortified his image as a gun for hire with no loyalty.
He has already undermined this season for Ole Miss by not signing a contract extension which I'm sure could be leveraged by the Florida offer.
But in the end he might feel he has a better chance at a NC at proven winner like Florida. He is somewhat similar to Steve Spurrier in personality. :lol:
But from my perspective his legacy could be improved considerably by winning a NC at a dark-horse like Ole Miss.
re: Matt Flynn ex LSU qb Radio Host says LSU needs to pay
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/12/25 at 6:11 am to bamalee
Flynn sharing the obvious.
A contract is a contract. If you don't think you are capable of honoring the contract then you best not sign it.
A contract is a contract. If you don't think you are capable of honoring the contract then you best not sign it.
re: SECR Power Rankings Vote - Week 11
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/11/25 at 11:18 am to TheDeathValley
A&M
Bama
Georgia
Ole Miss
Texas
OU
Vandy
Tennessee
LSU
Florida
SC
Kentucky
MSU
Arkansas
Bama
Georgia
Ole Miss
Texas
OU
Vandy
Tennessee
LSU
Florida
SC
Kentucky
MSU
Arkansas
re: New Mel Gibson Movie Trailer
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/10/25 at 6:09 pm to TygerTyger
You had me at Mel Gibson.
re: Nike Hiring NonBinary Furry in New Marketing Campaign
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/10/25 at 5:46 pm to Burt Reynolds
Nike doubling down on stupid. hahaa
re: My CFP Top 15 - Week Two
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/9/25 at 4:33 pm to Oklahomey
I think OSU and A&M are the 2 best teams.
So I would order them something like this:
1. OSU
2. A&M
3. Bama
4. Indiana
5. Georgia
6. Ole Miss
7. Oregon
8. TT
9. Texas
10. OU
So I would order them something like this:
1. OSU
2. A&M
3. Bama
4. Indiana
5. Georgia
6. Ole Miss
7. Oregon
8. TT
9. Texas
10. OU
re: Elko Ability On Full Display If You Paid Attention
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/9/25 at 7:02 am to BigSneezy
That was 2D chess.
3D chess will occur when the opposing team fakes that vulnerable look.
Having a skill player in position to receive the snap was a dead giveaway for anyone paying attention.
3D chess will occur when the opposing team fakes that vulnerable look.
Having a skill player in position to receive the snap was a dead giveaway for anyone paying attention.
re: Which Brad Pitt movie is better, “Legends of the Fall” or “A River Runs Through It”?
Posted by GurleyGirl on 11/6/25 at 7:48 am to theantiquetiger
A River Runs Through It for me.
It's simple film beautifully produced with multiple meaningful life lessons.
Even a short tragically flawed life can have great achievements and influences that make it worth living.
It's simple film beautifully produced with multiple meaningful life lessons.
Even a short tragically flawed life can have great achievements and influences that make it worth living.
Popular
0












