re: Hundreds of Marines investigated for posting naked photos of women recruits

quote:

---

As long as we have Marines in jobs like admin, supply, intel, etc. it will always be the case that women are sometimes more qualified than the men in those positions.

---

As long as we discuss the qualification of their serving, their simply being there provides a list of default negatives that never go away, many of which have been discussed here.

As you said, do you think it's ever the case that the positives out weigh the negatives in a preponderance of situations?

If not, is this a big diversity experiment runamok?

quote:

---

You would be if you knew what you were talking about.

---

And of course, you always know what you're talking about. We're all so very blessed that you deign to come here and share your knowledge with us. I'm sure we're all very, very thankful.

quote:

---

As long as we discuss the qualification of their serving, their simply being there provides a list of default negatives that never go away, many of which have been discussed here.

---

I never stated otherwise. In fact, I stated just that. I'm simply countering your assertion that there are zero positives. That's simply not true.

quote:

---

As you said, do you think it's ever the case that the positives out weigh the negatives in a preponderance of situations?

---

It could be, but I don't think SecNav or the Commandant want to hear my ideas.

quote:

---

If not, is this a big diversity experiment runamok?

---

To some extent, yes. But this is not a battle that will ever be won by stating that women don't belong, ragardless of how true that may be.

I'll be sure to take that into consideration.

quote:

---

But this is not a battle that will ever be won by stating that women don't belong, ragardless of how true that may be.

---

Why not? It's the truth. Thinking otherwise is what brought us the likes of Mabus and the neglecting of an entire study that proved men only marine units outperformed women and coed units in the field.

Unsurprisingly that report didn't go over well with the previous President's administration.

quote:

---

so basically they got passed around like peace pipes and are now mad because pics got out showing how big of sluts they actually were.

---

So they either took naked selfies or let someone else take a pic of themselves naked and sent them to SO's and now they mad because the military version of the Fappening went down?

quote:

---

So they either took naked selfies or let someone else take a pic of themselves naked and sent them to SO's and now they mad because the military version of the Fappening went down?

---

No.

quote:

---

No.

---

The pics were illegally taken, sold or traded?

quote:

---

Why not? It's the truth.

---

Because that's not the right argument, at least not as your first tangent. There are other arguments that are also true, and better.

quote:

---

Thinking otherwise is what brought us the likes of Mabus and the neglecting of an entire study that proved men only marine units outperformed women and coed units in the field.

---

Right, and this goes back to how we are used. If the best person for a specific position is a woman, she should fill that position. I don't give a frick if some analyst in DC can carry me or not. I care if she provides timely and accurate information.

Now, should that position be "equal" to an infantry Marine? I say no.

quote:

---

Not me....

---

Why not?

Shouldn't the Fappening be a reason why women shouldn't work in Hollywood if that's how you feel about women working in the military?