You right the throw outs at first look so close almost everytime to me, then slow motion comes and they’re 90% right, I even think the first baseman takes his foot off the bag before the catch but in slow motion never does. Although the strike zone seems to make the biggest difference, each umpire has his own.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by 62zip

One Particular Harbor

Member since Aug 2005

6702 posts

Posted on 5/14/25 at 3:02 pm to moneyg

quote:
quote:
I believe 1/3rd of calls are overturned on replay

Is that bad?

I'd be interested in knowing where this clown got his numbers from. Is he talking about NCAA?, MLB?, combination of the two? I'm not sure he even knows.

Also there is NFW that "1/3 of calls are overturned on replay." He may mean 1/3 of plays challenged, but he doesn't really express himself very well.

If it was "1/3 of plays" there would be multiple overturns per inning.

Now he can get butthurt and go ahead and downvote this post too like a little bitch.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by White Tiger

Dallas

Member since Jul 2007

13193 posts

Posted on 5/14/25 at 3:03 pm to wfallstiger

Does it really? Is the replay more accurate? If so then it may make for a better game. I prefer human judgment over replay but that is just I.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by 62zip

One Particular Harbor

Member since Aug 2005

6702 posts

Posted on 5/14/25 at 3:03 pm to Hermit Crab

quote:
So after the coaches/staff watch a slo mo replay and decide it is close enough to challenge, the refs/umps are still right 66% of the time at live speed. Not to mention all the calls they get right that aren't challenged?

It's hard to tell if that is what he means because he does an incredibly poor job of expressing himself.

It might be a little easier if he actually knew how to compose a sentence using a subject. Just saying.

Page 1 2 3