Item removed from Credit Report, then added back on. Score hit twice?

Got an account from a few years back that went bad. Went to collections, hit my credit report, hit my score. I took it as it is, rebounded back, and in the process of cleaning my report and my credit score has improved a hell of a whole lot.

Few days ago, I see that the item was removed from my report, and my score jumped.

Now today, I get an alert. The item was added BACK to my report and my score just got hit again.

So, same account, impacted my score twice.

I understand about paying it, but how do I address the item impacting my score two times?