Started By
Message

re: This is a very potent argument against the "2nd amendment means militia" talking point

Posted on 2/16/21 at 8:29 pm to
Posted by Jyrdis
TD Premium Member Level III
Member since Aug 2015
12828 posts
Posted on 2/16/21 at 8:29 pm to
quote:

Are you really comparing The U.S. to Iraq?


quote:

I recognize our population is far more capable than the Iraqi population.

That said, it does show that without airpower even a decently capable ground force is just a bunch of targets to a modern military force.


Lol. So even in your response to me where you acknowledged that Afghanistan had to be rooted out—and we never really did that successfully—that a decently capable ground force is actually incapable.

You’ll need to address the size of the US populace, the size of the US military and the ability for current US citizens in the military willing and able to fire on their own countrymen. As an analogy, it’s estimated only 1/3 of colonists fought against their own. Take away 1/3 of the military and you’ve created a pretty vast gap. Lastly, it’s not about the nation at that point. It’s about defending your home.
Posted by BornAndRaised_LA
Springfield, VA
Member since Oct 2018
5275 posts
Posted on 2/16/21 at 8:38 pm to
quote:

You’ll need to address the size of the US populace, the size of the US military and the ability for current US citizens in the military willing and able to fire on their own countrymen. As an analogy, it’s estimated only 1/3 of colonists fought against their own. Take away 1/3 of the military and you’ve created a pretty vast gap.


Nowhere in this thread am I discussing the US military attacking our own soil or people. I’m discussing (and have been throughout) the problem with the Founding Fathers’ preference for a militia over a standing army and how that no longer works in the modern world.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram