re: Eli, Big Ben and P Rivers

quote:

---

If you gave me the choice of any of the three with the same supporting cast I'd take Rivers.

---

I agree, but that wasn't the question. You could maybe make that arguement with Rivers and Eli because Eli has really only had a couple seasons of really good play, but when you combine the three Superbowl appearances, 2 wins, the AFC Championship appearences, and the elite play for most of his career you have to put Ben above Rivers no doubt