First off your initial response is false. SEC had LSU 03 and Auburn 04 both finish in the top 5, if you're willing to lie about that who knows what other fallacies you're posting. The facts are the win pct of the sec west during both tenures was the same saying one was better is completely wrong and untrue that's a fact. And saying one was elite and the other garbage as you've repeatedly said is not only biased it's stupid. You keep harping on what the top teams in the division did but the division consists of 6/7 teams. All you're doing us proving its top heavy in those years not better top to bottom. And I only brought up those rankings because you were hooping and hollering about it. You flip flop on what is valid as you go along so don't blame me for trying to argue on your terms I can't stop you from changing them at will.

This post was edited on 7/15/17 at 2:21 am

2 Jump to Post ...

Report Post Jump to Post

Posted by Rickdaddy4188

Murfreesboro,TN

Member since Aug 2011

46787 posts

Posted on 7/15/17 at 2:18 am to Madking

quote:
The facts are the win pct of the sec west during both tenures was the same saying one was better is completely wrong and untrue that's a fact.

so 3 different west programs winning a NC to 1 program isn't better?

playing 9 top 10 opponents to 2 isnt better?

playing 5 top 5 opponents isnt better than playing 1 top 5 opponent?

it's fricking amazing how you've taken a stance thats no one on the fricking planet but you thinks.

in 3 of Saban's 5 years tenure no west program had less than 3 losses.

youre basing your entire argument over 1 stat. win %.

top 10 west opponents faced

Saban-2
miles- 9

top 5 west opponents faced
Saban-1
Miles-5

west teams that won the west with 3 losses
Saban-3
miles-0
west teams that won the west with 4 losses
saban- 1
miles-0

national title winning teams faced
saban-0
miles-2

west programs to win a NC
Saban-1
miles-3

only a fricking retard would take 1 stat over 6 stats thats heavily in favor of one stretch

youre the only one that believes your bullshite stance lirerally no one on this thread agrees with you.

but by all means cling to your one stat that even favors 2011-2015.

you've already established your bias wheb you saod you didn't care about subjective rankings when your 1st response about this issue had rankings in it.

face facts. The west garbage compared to 2011-2015.

1 Jump to Post ...

Report Post Jump to Post

Posted by Rickdaddy4188

Murfreesboro,TN

Member since Aug 2011

46787 posts

Posted on 7/15/17 at 2:34 am to Madking