re: Possibly the GOAT south park episode is on

quote:

---

14) Scott Tenorman Must Die (5x04) is too low

---

Here's my defense on it being that low:

quote:

---

This episode is like one very long filthy joke. Aside from Cartman gluing pubes to his face, the episode really isn't that funny until the punch line, but holy hell its one of the most notorious punch lines ever for a show and one of the greatest plot twists ever. Like "The Red Badge of Gayness", this episode saw a great change to Cartman's character. From this episode forward, Cartman became much more sinister, threatening, and horrifying child. This is the first episode Cartman has really gotten his way for something terrible (its like the Coyote catching the Road Runner) and no parent in their right mind from that day forward would allow their kid anywhere near him.

---

quote:

---

Make Love, Not Warcraft =/= top 25 is suspect.

---

That narrowly missed the mark. I remember when making the list that I thought it was the biggest missed episode, and I chose Trapped in the Closet over it. But I like all 25 of those episodes more than that one. Yes, a great episode, but there are shite tons of South Park episodes. Not an insult to the episode that its not in my Top 25.