re: Could the NFL all-rookie team beat the worst team in the league?

quote:

---

I say no. And it's not close

---

LT- Duane Brown, J. Long, K.Dunlap
RT- Clady, Polumbus, Albert
C- De la Puente, Lichtensteiger, M.Pollack
LG- Sitton
RG- C.Nicks, Bernardeau

QB- M.Ryan, Flacco
RB- Charles, Forte, CJ2K, R.Rice, Stewart. McFadden

FB- Tolbert, Reece, Hester, Hillis

WR- J.Nelson, Garçon,
WR-Desean Jackson, Manningham
WR-Amendola, E. Bennett
TE- M.Bennett, J.Finley, D.Keller, J.Carlson
***************************
DE- C. Avril, Dorsey
DE- C.Long, W.Hayes, J.Jones
DT- C.Campbell, R.Bryant, Hayden, P.Sims
LB- J.Mayo, T.Gooden, G.Haynes
LB- Lofton, Walden, E.Henderson
LB- D.Connor, W.Woodyard
CB- Talib, B.Carr, C.Williams, M.Jenkins
CB- Rogers-Cromartie, T.Porter, Flowers
CB-Scandrick, McKelvin, K.Arrington
CB- Terrell Thomas, Trae Williams
S- K.Phillips, Q.Demps
S- DeCoud, T. Johnson

K- D.Carpenter

~~~~ you can't tell me that this squad wouldn't TROUNCE the Browns for starters.
Weakest link is safety, and CB class, so deep, one of those CB's could transition to FS.
And if you say because no punter is listed, it invalidates the list ....

Was surprised how stacked the 2008 draft was.