Shaq was dominant inside. Not competent, not great, but dominant. In trancendent fashion.

I have watched a number of lottery picks come through this program, more than one of them in person. And each and every one of them had some facet of the game where they were simply dominant: Shaq's inside game, offensively (eventually) and defensively; CJ's perimeter game, FTs and ball handling; Tyrus Thomas' athleticism and defense inside; etc. There is nothing about Simmons' game that is that level of dominant. He is without doubt a highly talented inside man and great rebounder, and handles the ball and passes much better than most guys who have his size. And if he had an all around game that was solid or better in all phases, he would be that rare complete package that would be so attractive. But he turns the ball over fairly often, has little to no medium or long range scoring ability, and isn't even a lock at the free throw line (under 75%).

What should be remembered is that none of those other guys were lottery picks as true freshmen, though (although CJ may well have been had he come out his first year). Simmons seems to have an amazing amount of talent, but it is not yet developed to a dominant degree at this level of basketball. So while he does score well, he is hardly unstoppable. And he is a good defender, but hardly a shut-down machine. And he is a good passer and ball handler, but not like having a 6'10" super point guard. And he plays a bit out of control sometimes. Honestly, he really does look like someone who is a bit surprised that his sheer size, talent and athleticism isn't dominating his competition anymore and hasn't quite adjusted to it. When he does, he could very well be a clear #1 draft pick and easily the best player in the country.

But he's just not there yet, imo.