re: Name your top 10 SGs of all time

quote:

---

When MJ was the man, no Pippen, he never made it out of the 1st round.

When Kobe was the man, no Shaq/Gasol, how successful was he?

But you're only holding that against Wade, just seems strange.

---

Shel, you quoted my take on his time with the Heatles, I responded and then you respond with a different quote? It's seeems like you agree that Wade's importance in the Heatles was little.

quote:

---

When MJ was the man, no Pippen, he never made it out of the 1st round.

When Kobe was the man, no Shaq/Gasol, how successful was he?

But you're only holding that against Wade, just seems strange.

---

I wouldn't say MJ was in his prime before Pippen arrived.
I would say Kobe was in a much tougher conference.
I would say Prime Wade was in one of the weakest conferences ever.


Wade,statistically speaking, is on a downward trend.

Wade on a (rumored)3 year deal? Imagine 36 year old DWade's game.Gaudy career numbers will regress just like Allen,T-Mac and Carter.

and again

quote:

---

Jordan
Kobe
West

Gervin
Drexler
T-Mac

Carter
Allen
Wade
Moncrief

---

In the two groups ahead him, I don't think Prime Wade could take any of those guys in their prime one-on-one.