re: Am I wrong?

We had a similar issue with my pug. Pugs are stubborn as hell and even though they are housetrained...they will still go inside every now and then just to say "frick you". We did the crate thing to solve that issue. Works great. Your gf should have taken the time to try the crate solution. Dogs really don't mind being in the crate. Mine runs to his now whenever he feels scared(ex: I turn the vacuum cleaner on).




To answer your question....you didn't make her get rid of the dog...she choose that. You gave her a perfectly good option to compromise and allow her to keep the dog and for you to not deal with dog piss. If she really wanted to keep her dog....she would have done everything she could to keep it and keep you happy.