re: New Orleans Federal Court hears same-sex marriage case today.

quote:

---

Do you really think that the four liberal IDIOTS on the court actually wanted to sign their names onto the majority opinion? Do you think that it represents their true beliefs?

---

yea it seems to fall in line to thier previous opinions pretty closely.

Anthony isn't considered a liberal of the court by most commentators, but he generally goes personal ilberties top most everything else so no suprise he authored the opinion.

quote:

---

Second, once again, clearly you haven't read the opinion.

---

I have and its clear you are taking scalia's dissent said and what he characterized the majority opinion as and taking it as what the majority opinion said.

not saying that it is wrong, but it is obvious. and makes me believe that you only read his dissent

I just searched the document: Kennedy never once in his opinion said the words (unless quoting) hate, injury, mocked congress for enacting such a statue
He said the statute demeans homosexuals and they should be given the same dignity etc.

I have the document open on westlaw as i though i might have misread it or characterized Kennedy's opinion. But i dont think i did.