re: Star Wars - A New Hope: How Flawed is it?

quote:

---

if this is aimed at me, i said it was flawed as in it has flaws yet is still seen as great(which i clarified in the other thread).

---

It was a starting point, this thread isn't though. It was a good question to ask. You know, what does a flaw do to a film. Does it deaden all impact. What kind of "flaws," are real "flaws?" How is "greatness" determined.

Though, your comparison was with Man of Steel, which is kind of crazy. To say that Man of Steel is a great film that has flaws and that Star Wars is a great film that has flaws are two very very different things. But it provides context for a different type of discussion.