re: So, McShay has Mettenberger going no earlier than the 4th round...w/ link

quote:

---

Brady, Manning, Eli, etc say "sup"

---

Those guys are future hall of famers who are not only athletic, but obviously bring other rare skill-sets like pocket presence, poise, and accuracy to the game. Pump the brakes on comparing Mettenberger to three of the top QBs of an era; two are certainly among the best of all time.

ETA: And no one is calling Mett garbage. Assessing him as a mid-round draft pick after a college career that most would rate as decent and a serious knee injury is not at all a ridiculous proposition.