re: Can Miles convince some of our Juniors to stick around?

quote:

---

Hilliard- no. Wouldn't be drafted at all.
Collins- not ready.
Johnson- not ready.
Hill - no
Ego- maybe, but could use another year.

---

Um, why did you change my list and then use it as a quote? Pretty dick move, IMO. I said not sure on Hill, not "no".

You really think Hilliard would be drafted? I thnk he'd be lucky to make it to a practice roster.

You really think Collins and Johnson are ready? These are supposedly elite talents, and they've had pretty uneven seasons/careers. Right now, I'd put both in maybe the 3rd rd at best, while a good senior year should make them 1st rd picks.

edited to add- I'm also a Saints fan, and I take "ready for the NFL" to mean- yeah, I'd like them on my Saints team.

Beckham and Landry, yes. They can come in and play. Hill- I'm not sure just yet. I'd love to know if he can play a whole season as the man, before I'd want to spend a draft pick on him. Collins- no. Don't draft an underperforming early entry. We need a tackle you can rely on, and he hasn't been that yet. Johnson and Ferguson are servicable guys for depth; nothing special.

Given that each has the oppurtunity to play another year in college and improve on what they've done, the WRs are the only guys who I'd take without hesitation, before the 4th round. Hill and Collins, ok for middle rds and hope for the best, if there's nobody better.