re: Let's have a GB Roundtable: What are the best games of this console generation?

Best First Person Shooter: I was about to say Halo 2, but forgot that it was original Xbox, so I will go with COD4. It was an absolute game changer in modern military shooter.

Best Third Person Shooter: The Mass Effect Series. I think 1 has the best story, 2 is the most fun, and 3 has the best controls and feel as shooter.

Best Open World Role Playing Game: Skyrim

Best Sports Game: The NHL series. (Never played the Show)

Best Racing Game: Burnout: Paradise

Best Playstation 3 Exclusive:

Best Xbox 360 Exclusive: Fable 2 or Halo: Reach

Biggest Overall Bust of This Generation: COD: World at War. The Zombie mode was a massive update to the series, but a massive flop in comparison to the rest of the series

Best Overall Console Game of This Generation: Battlefield 3

Edited to add:

Best Indie Game: State of Decay (does this count)

Most Overlooked/Underrated Game (AKA "The Moped"): I will put State of Decay here as well