Started By
Message

re: LHSAA--Anybody heard any rumors about the LHSAA Executive Director's job?

Posted on 1/24/13 at 11:53 am to
Posted by supatigah
CEO of the Keith Hernandez Fan Club
Member since Mar 2004
88031 posts
Posted on 1/24/13 at 11:53 am to
LINK

From Curtis to Karr, concerns about fair playing field continue
Posted by: Ed Daniels in Prep Sports on Nov 07, 2012

'PLAYING UP' PART OF ONGOING DEBATE

The calls began Tuesday and continued into Wednesday morning. When I answered, it went like this.
"Hey, Ed. What is J.T. gonna do?"
Some high school coaches and administrators were hoping they could avoid two football seasons in the same classification as John Curtis Christian school.
I heard from one school that actually "desired" to be in the same class as Curtis.
But that was a rarity indeed.
Ultimately, Curtis informed the LHSAA it would compete the next two seasons in Class 3A moments before the noon deadline.
For years, when I heard complaints about the alleged unlevel playing field in Louisiana high school football, those gripes centered around Curtis and Evangel.
There was relative quiet from the public schools when Curtis and Evangel both competed in class 2A.
In 5A, West Monroe was still dominant. In 4A, Neville and Franklinton were two of the powerhouses.
But now there is a new school that is in the crosshairs of this debate.
Edna Karr, welcome to the spotlight. The Cougars are now churning out Division I stars and Superdome Classic appearances.
Quarterback Munchie Legaux is a star at the University of Cincinnati. The current Karr quarterback, Speedy Noil, is being recruited by many BCS schools including LSU.
Karr's best player is a defensive end. His name is Gerald Willis. He is listed as 6-foot-3, 255 pounds. In week 10 against O Perry Walker, Willis made a one-handed interception of a screen pass and then outraced the opposing offensive skill players to the end zone.
Frankly, I didn't hear too much complaining about Karr, until the last two years. That's when the Cougars made back-to-back trips to the state 4A championship game.
Now, I am hearing that Karr has an unfair advantage as a member of the Algiers Charter schools.
Those schools have open enrollment. If you live in the city of New Orleans, you can attend Edna Karr.
Indeed, Karr has a lot going for it. Head coach Jabbar Juluke is an experienced head coach who plays top flight competition. He has turned out a lot of football players that seem to have no problem making good grades and good test scores.
Two of his recent troops are LSU offensive lineman Derek Edinburgh and Tulane defensive back Shakiel Smith.
At the end of this school year, defensive back Collin Early could be headed to the Ivy League.
As for "fairness," I really don't know how to legislate it.
Maybe the right move is to drop attendance zones completely.
If you live in Orleans, go to school anywhere in the parish. Same for Jefferson, St Tammany, and so forth.
I don't have all the answers. But a split playoff certainly isn't it.
It would be bad for Louisiana high school football.
And, as an athletic director told me Wednesday in Baton Rouge, the public schools should play nice. Soon, they will be in the minority.
Posted by supatigah
CEO of the Keith Hernandez Fan Club
Member since Mar 2004
88031 posts
Posted on 1/24/13 at 12:08 pm to
Nonselect vs. select sparks plenty debate at LHSAA meeting

Select school administrators discuss options for dividing LHSAA

LHSAA considers dividing schools between select, nonselect for playoffs
quote:

Key differences
The South Beauregard plan calls for separate championships in football and seven other sports: baseball, basketball, cross country, soccer, softball and outdoor track and field and volleyball.

This means select and non-select schools will continue to compete against each other in swimming, gymnastics, bowling, wrestling, powerlifting, tennis, indoor track and golf for LHSAA titles. The football-only proposal makes no provision for other sports.

The proposals differ on the percentage of students a dual-curriculum school must draw from outside its attendance zone in order to be considered select.

The South Beauregard proposal calls for 33 percent. The football-only proposal calls for 25 percent. Henderson has told LHSAA principals his staff does not have dual-curriculum percentages and would have to obtain them.

Because the South Beauregard proposal was tabled last year, a vote will be required to get it considered. The football only proposal is in line for consideration.


By the numbers
The 92-year-old LHSAA has 388 member schools. Of that group, there are 90 private schools, 19 charter schools, eight full magnet schools, three lab schools and 21 schools with magnet components that are dual-curriculum schools. Private schools make up 20.6 percent of the membership. Factoring in the maximum number of dual-curriculum schools makes the possible select percent 30.9.

The LHSAA agenda has breakdowns on where schools would fall in the select/nonselect categories. Several schools are shaded in gray, noting their status as dual-curriculum schools that could be either select or nonselect.

Also shaded in gray are Louisiana Recovery School District members coded as nonselect schools, noting those schools could be converted into charter schools. That list of five schools includes Sarah Reed-New Orleans, and four schools in the BR area: Capitol, Istrouma, Pointe Coupee Central and St. Helena Central.

Henderson said he has been told different things about the status of New Orleans schools, Eleanor McMain and McDonogh 35. Are they full magnet schools or dual curriculum? That’s just one question that must be answered.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram