re: UCL Quarter Final Round April 3, 2012

quote:

---

This is stupid. PK is by definition a result of a foul in the box.

---

I think he was saying it was a foul but shouldn't have been called. I don't really want to get into this now because the game just started again, but just because a foul was committed (although I'm not conceding the point that a I think nothing should have been called in that situation) doesn't mean a penalty is called for.

A penalty and a card for mutual jostling at the top of the box away from the play in a massive match, while maybe a foul occurd, it should not be called because the crime does not fit the punishment.