re: Dennis Quaid as Doc Holiday -vs- Val Kilmer as Doc Holiday

quote:

---

Is there anyone who thinks Quaid was the better Holiday?

---

Me...in terms of being more historically accurate. Don't get me wrong, I think Kilmer's turn as Holiday was a phenominal role and he nailed it...I just found Quaid's performance better.

I tend to like Costner's Wyatt Earp movie better for the same reason. Tombstone was hella fun, but it was more MTV, shoot 'em up, one liner whereas Wyatt Earp was more of an epic western.

Both were great...