re: Star rankings for NFL draft Rd.1

quote:

---

They grade it as:

5* - instant impact player with high draft pick written all over them

4* - all-american potential player who has high draft ceiling

3* - usually raw but has NFL ceiling and sometimes a varying late/high draft ceiling potential or all-american potential after heavy development. raw that need refining and usually slow developers.

2*, 1*, NR are players that the recruiting services simply shite the bed on because their resources are limited. They're not a big name, they don't go to camps, they slip through cracks. Obviously all have to develop some slower than others which is hard to project and why you get your busts

---

This is a solid grading philosophy. Whose is it?

I've had a problem with 247's 5* philosophy where they drop guys based on how NFL teams draft their position. So like, they would drop a guard from 5* status because NFL teams supposedly don't draft a lot of guards in the first round.