Updated Heisman Trophy Odds - Sept. 2, 2025

Online Sportsbook BetOnline released updated Heisman Trophy odds this week, with LSU quarterback Garrett Nussmeier at 15/2 (+750).

Oklahoma passer John Mateer is the current favorite at 7/1.

Nussmeier passed for 230 yards and one touchdown in the season-opening win at Clemson. He was 28-of-38 with a 73.7 completion percentage.


2025 Heisman Trophy
John Mateer 7/1
Garrett Nussmeier 15/2 (+750)
Gunner Stockton 12/1
LaNorris Sellers 12/1
Cade Klubnik 14/1
Jeremiah Smith 14/1
Arch Manning 16/1
Dante Moore 16/1
Jeremiyah Love 16/1
Carson Beck 18/1
Drew Allar 18/1
Jackson Arnold 18/1
Sam Leavitt 20/1
Devon Dampier 22/1
DJ Lagway 22/1
Thomas Castellanos 25/1
Austin Simmons 33/1
Bryce Underwood 33/1
Julian Sayin 33/1
Marcel Reed 33/1
Ty Simpson 33/1
Kevin Jennings 35/1
CJ Carr 40/1
Beau Pribula 50/1
Haynes King 50/1
Jalon Daniels 50/1
Ryan Williams 50/1
Miller Moss 55/1
Avery Johnson 66/1
Demond Williams Jr 66/1
Fernando Mendoza 66/1
Jayden Maiava 66/1
Josh Hoover 66/1
Dylan Raiola 100/1
Sawyer Robertson 100/1
Eli Holstein 150/1
Kyron Drones 150/1
Nico Iamaleava 150/1
Steve Angeli 150/1