re: The best and worst starting QB in your favorite NFL team history?

Posted by SamuelClemens

Earth

Member since Feb 2015

11727 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 5:28 pm to sms151t

Best: Drew

Worst: Billy Joe (either one)

Posted by kywildcatfanone

Wildcat Country!

Member since Oct 2012

119245 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 5:47 pm to sms151t

Best: Ken Anderson
Worst: David Klingler/Akili Smith

Posted by FightinTigersDammit

Louisiana North

Member since Mar 2006

34715 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 5:55 pm to JBeam

quote:
Bengals: Best:Boomer Esiason

Ken Anderson?

Posted by lsutigers1992

Member since Mar 2006

25317 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:08 pm to FightinTigersDammit

Unless I've missed it, nobody's surprisingly done Atlanta

Best: Matt Ryan
Worst: Randy Johnson (10-38-1 as expansion starter)
Worst non-expansion: Scott Campbell

Posted by Bigpoppat

Drinking a Manhattan

Member since Oct 2008

9216 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:14 pm to FleurDeLonestar

quote:
Troy Aikmen

Quincy Carter

You figure out who's best/worst

Romo is much better than Aikmen

Posted by lsutigers1992

Member since Mar 2006

25317 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:16 pm to lsutigers1992

Browns

Best: Otto Graham
Best Super Bowl Era: Bernie Kosar
Worst: 5-way tie (Tim Couch, Brady Quinn, Colt McCoy, Jeff Garcia, Johnny Manziel)

2 ...

Posted by Dawgsontop34

Member since Jun 2014

42567 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:18 pm to lsutigers1992

Best: Roger Staubach

Worst: Drew Henson

Posted by lsutigers1992

Member since Mar 2006

25317 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:20 pm to lsutigers1992

Cardinals would be interesting.

I don't know that Kurt Warner was there long enough to be the one. But after him, it's Jim Hart, Neil Lomax or Jake Plummer.

Worst? Where do you begin? But it'll be hard to top Ryan Lindley.

Posted by Party At LSU

Baton Rouge

Member since Nov 2005

10694 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:22 pm to lsutigers1992

Dan Marino

Ray Lucas

Posted by Draconian Sanctions

Markey's bar

Member since Oct 2008

84876 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:22 pm to sms151t

Best is Joe Montana

Worst is probably Jim Drunkenmiller

Posted by lsutigers1992

Member since Mar 2006

25317 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:24 pm to RollTide1987

quote:
Worst: Jim Drunkenmiller

Surprisingly, Druckenmiller started one game and won it.

There's a chance their worst long-term QB is Jim Plunkett.

Posted by brmark70816

Atlanta, GA

Member since Feb 2011

9802 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:29 pm to cubsfan5150

quote:
Off the top of my head, Theismann Shuler

As a Redskin fan, I'd disagree. I'd go..

Best- Rypien (QB of the greatest team in NFL history)

Worst- McNabb.. some played worst, but none ever were a bigger letdown. Plus he played in the most embarrassing loss ever for me, getting destroyed by Vick and the Eagles on a Monday night, after a bye week, with a .500 record. The season was done after that game.

2 ...

Posted by Kracka

Lafayette, Louisiana

Member since Aug 2004

40813 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:37 pm to geauxjuice

quote:

worst is anyone outside of brees manning brooks and blake

My worst for the saints has to be Danny Wuerffel or one of the Billy Joe's.

Posted by Draconian Sanctions

Markey's bar

Member since Oct 2008

84876 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:39 pm to lsutigers1992

quote:
Surprisingly, Druckenmiller started one game and won it.

Yeah against the Rams. He was woeful and threw 3 or 4 picks if memory serves. He was dreadful. 1st round pick too.

Posted by tigerfan84

Member since Dec 2003

20296 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 6:59 pm to sms151t

Brees
either Bily Jo

Posted by Taurus

Loozianna

Member since Feb 2015

4955 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 7:07 pm to sms151t

Who would love to have the Colts dilemma in choosing the best?

Unitas, Manning, Jones, Morrall, and now Luck.

Yeah, the top 2 are easy, but that is a nice list of good QB's

Posted by Wayne Campbell

Aurora, IL

Member since Oct 2011

6374 posts

Posted on 6/28/15 at 7:15 pm to sms151t

Best: Elway.

Worst: Tebow.