Planning Trip With Wife - Jamaica, Cabo, or Other?

Looking to make a trip to the Carribbean or Cabo in April 4 nights - 3 days (no kids). We are a 29 years old couple. Looking for an all-inclusive resort in Jamaica or Cabo but are open to other places within our price range. We are looking to keep it around $3,500 with flights. Looking for good food and good beach.

So far we have a few options we are looking at that seem to fall within our price range:

Jamaica - couples negril, Hyatt Zillara

Cabo - Pueblo Bonita, Sandos Finisterra, Riu Palace

Anyone have any suggestions from previous stays? Does anyone feel strongly on Jamaica Vs. Cabo? better beach? Any other islands/places we should closer at in the Caribbean that will fall within our price range?

Thanks in advance for any help!