re: Is Andrew Luck the most overrated QB in NFL?

Overrated??? according to ESPN before he was drafted he already had 6 SB rings, he just needed to put his helmet on to claim them.

He and Big Ben alike both make their lines look worse then they are, they hold on to the ball forever trying to make something out of nothing, it just works out for Big Ben a lot more than luck. Ben is built stronger and has been able to endure the hits but his career will quickly wind down as soon as he starts to get hurt he'll always be hurt and the play extensions will deminish and so will the offense.

Russell Wilson is a bad QB IMO, he's like a luckier Manzelle but his time is short as well, eventually he's gonna get clobbered out there as well.

Luck may progress I wouldn't throw him away yet but I can't see why he might get it together once in a 15 year career for a SB ring, and that ain't all that bad.

The most overated is Eli Manning and then of course Romo.