re: Games you could use the MIB memory flashy thingy with....

I haven't even scratched the surface on enough games since I started playing again the past couple years but of my limited recent experience, I'd have to say Mass Effect and RDR.

I know, graphics and gameplay on ME are meh but that's probably my favorite game I've played on 360. Maybe ME 1a and RDR 1b

I loved both stories and it would be fun to go back through not knowing what was next. Really I could probably play ME and take a different approach and it still be somewhat new. I really need to start ME2. It's been staring at me for almost 2 years patiently waiting

eta: I understood your description perfectly. Just wanted to be the first dick in the thread