re: How meaningful are STARS? Player evaluations

I just don't buy into all the hype of what makes one guy a five star and the other a four stars, Sam and Reid were both four stars and will both go top ten in next years draft. And then you have a kid like Chris Davenport who had a big frame but played in 2A and was all-star gets a 5 star rating and will never set foot on the field as a starter. Talent is talent but I don't see the point in following who has the most five stars and which class is ranked the highest when some of the most unproductive players in the past 5 years have been 4 and 5 stars.....shepard, loston, davenport, dickson, allen, copeland (DT to FB), and cant forget JJ. I'm not trying to hate on these guys but I'm not buying as much into these ranking and star systems as everyone else. I think these rivals and scout class rankings are meaningless 1-10.